Rev. John DuBois, 1808-1826
Rev. Michael DeBurgo Egan, 1826-1828
Rev. John McGerry, 1828-1829
Rev. John B. Purcell, 1829-1833
Rev. Francis B. Jamison, 1833-1834
Rev. Thomas R. Butler, 1834-1838
Rev. John McCaffrey, 1838-1872
Rev. John McCloskey, 1872-1877
Rev. John A. Watterson, 1877-1880
Rev. John McCloskey 1880
Rev. William J. Hill, 1880-1881
Rev. William G. Byrne, 1881-1885
Rev. Edward P. Allen, 1885-1897
Rev. William L. O’Hara, 1897-1905
Rt. Rev. Msgr. Dennis J. Flynn, 1905-1911
Rt. Rev. Msgr. Bernard J. Bradley, 1911-1936
Rt. Rev. Msgr. John L. Sheridan, 1936-1961
Rev. Msgr. Robert R. Kline, 1961-1967
Rev. Msgr. Hugh J. Phillips, 1967-1971
John J. Dillon Jr., 1971-1977
Robert J. Wickenheiser, 1977-1993
Rev. James N. Loughran, S.J., 1993-1994
George R. Houston Jr., 1994-2003